Mandeep Singh English 10

Thursday, January 04, 2007



The enigma I was in, and the simplicity that depicted many aspects.

Reaction Journal

Pages 1-10
Page number 2-3

"Man raises himself toward God by the questions he asks him," he was fond of repeating. "That is the true dialogue. Man questions God and God answers. But we do not understand His answers. We can't understand them. Because they come from the depths of the soul and they stay there until death. You will find the true answers, Eliezer, only within yourself!"

The quote is captivated only in a few sentences, but these few sentences depict so many aspects. The depth they go in is breathtaking, and perhaps can lose somebody in an enigma; in a labyrinth of ideas. I found this quote meaningful, because it lost me in a puzzle. I can relate this quote to myself, so maybe that it why I find it meaningful. I personally question God, but I do not find the answers to my questions. I cry, and question God Why? Little did I know that this Why is in me , and all I need to do is discern them. The answer is in me, it strikes me, the answer is in me. It's just hard for me to explain why this quote is so meaningful to me. Maybe, it's because it makes me realize something, the feeling that it aroused, and the concepts that assail in my mind. I can surely say that this quote touches somewhere that makes it sacred and that is in my soul, this is the most prompt response I can give you.

Pages 1-10
Page number 3

"There are a thousand and one gates leading into the orchard of mystical truth. Every human being has his own gate. We must never make the mistake of wanting to enter the orchard gate but our own. To do this is dangerous for the one who enters and also for those who are already there."

I find this quote meaningful, because perhaps I do not know the true meaning of this quote. I do not understand the depth, and the meaning that the author is trying the penetrate. However, I can ensemble my own meaning. Well, Eliezer was unhappy because he could not find a master that would teach him Zohar, and after that Moshe the Beadle gave this response. I think that it means that some paths, one will find on their own, and the path will come to them. They do not need to look for it, the time, the right time will come on its own. The truth. The answer will be found simultaneously, and sometimes its detrimental to look for the truth, the answer. Sometimes one must wait, and the good rests in this wait. I think that this quote is so complex that I can only give my opinion on what this quote means. I think that this quote is trying to say that sometimes waiting for the response is better than going out to look for it, because the truth, the answer will come on the right time.

Pages 11-20
Page number 14

"There was joy-yes, joy. Perhaps they thought that God could have devised no torment in hell worse than that of sitting here among the bundles, in the middle of the road beneath a lazing sun; that anything would be preferable to that. They began their journey without a backward glance at the abandoned street's the dead empty houses, the gardens, the tombstones...On everyone's eyes was suffering drowned in tears. Slowly, heavily, the procession made its way to the gate of the ghetto."

The human nature is vulnerable to pessimism, but the light of the day will not let the pessism undermine it. This quote is meaningful, because it exemplifies the human nature. Calamities, and atrocities might break on a human, but the human as a being cannot lose hope. Hope will always prevail, and it will always live.They were facing problems, and their hearts, and souls were burdened with pain and devastation, but they needed the light. The light that would ensure that the dawn of tomorrow will be better, and that everything will be fine. This quote is meaningful because it shows that no matter how much a human being is vulnerable-a human being cannot lose hope. Or the very nature of this vulnerable human will not allow it to lose hope.

Pages 21-30
Page number 25

"Walking with a start we rushed to the window. Yet again we had believed her, even if only for a moment. But there was nothing outside save the darkness of night. With shame in spite in our souls, we went back to our places, gnawed by fear, in spite of ourselves. As she continued to scream, they began to hit her again, and it was with the greatest difficulty that they silenced her."

I find this quote a very important part of the book. Madam was giving a premonition. A premonition that something atrocious is coming their way. The other captives were all slithered up with their fears, anxieties, and problems. In this phase they ignored their future, and the voice of their fellow inmates. They ignored her voice and it foreshadowed a concept; that in this struggle the only person that would matter was oneself. This quote also discerns a change, and the change is a new fear. This quote exemplifies that their inner voices are being silenced, and the beneficiary is that they remain like this. They felt sorry for her, and they probably somewhere knew that she was right, however bitten by their own quandaries they do not want to take up a new danger a new problem. So, the silence is the awakening of the storm that is about to strike them.

Pages 31-40
Page number 32

"Never shall I forget that nocturnal silence which deprived me, for all eternity, of the desires to live. Never shall I forget those moments which murdered my God and my soul and turned my dreams to dust. Never shall I forget these things, even if I am condemned to live as long as God himself. Never."

This quote shows the human natures vulnerability to pessimism, and portrays the right feelings. This quote touched because it showed the right feelings, and is blunt, but true. The phase Elie was in most people would be complelty torn up, and would question the very god they had so keenly wanted to know more about. In their minds they forget all the happiness, and the devotion they had to that very God. Now, they wonder why are they in these quandaries, and the question, and question so keenly wanting to know the answer, but the answer does not come, and their left with this bitterness, and hollowness. The bitterness that will always take the pessimistic side of everything. So, what they do is they deny the very existence Since he is not able to give them their response. I think this quote is very meaningful because is shows the murder of their dreams, of their trust, of their faith, and of their hope.

Pages 41-50
Page number 42

"Akiba Drumer said: "God is testing us, He wants to find out whether we can dominate our base instincts and kill the Satan within us, We have no right to despair. And if he punishes us relentlessly, it's a sign that He loves us all the more."

I find this quote very meaningful, and very deep. I find it meaningful because it is true. If we learn to kill the Satan inside us, then we forever will be able to go through all the storms, and problems that come ashore. Those problems will seem like their not even problems, because the biggest enemy can be ourselves sometimes. Our self can be very enemy, and if it wants will try to divert out attention in the wrong direction, But if we learn to kill that very devil that very poison than not even tornado can destroy our happiness. If one can control a, and crush that poison, and deny that very existence of it then no problem will seem tremendous. We also have no right to despair , but it seems inevitable not to. We cannot deny all the happiness that God had given us, and if today their is a problem then we have no right to despair. That is true we have no right to despair. However, so hard to believe this , and accept everything as good. When the problems are attacking, and everything seems snatched-the optimism is gone, and it is very hard to bring it back. To think on the bright side. How simple to say, yet so hard to do. This quote gives a message, and the message is surely deep.

Pages 51-60
Page number

"I had watched the whole scene without moving. I kept quiet, In fact I was thinking of how to get farther away so that I would not be hit myself, What is more any anger I felt at that moment was directed not against the Kapo, but against my father. I was angry with him, for not knowing how to avoid Idek's outbreak, That is what concentration life had made of me."

The face of reality can change the nature of any human being, and it was also changing the behavior of Elie's. His silence is a symbolism of the drowning of his nature. The only reason he had seen his father being beaten was because of the problems he has gone through. He has seen a lot, and because of that his voice was silenced, and he remained quite. Maybe, if he had not witnessed everything that he had then maybe he would have been different . Maybe, he would have raised his voice,a and stopped the person form beating him. He also realizes that he is changing, but cannot do anything do anything about it, because he knows that if he raises his voice then that will only augment to the problems, and not cease the problems.

Pages 61-70
Page number 65

"This day I had ceased to plead. I was no longer capable of lamentation. On the contrary, I felt very strong. I was the accuser, God the accused. My eyes were open and I was alone-terribly alone in a world without God and without man, Without love or mercy. I had ceased to be anything but ashes, yet I felt myself to be stronger that the Almighty, to whom my life had been tied for so long, I stood amid that praying congregation, observing it like a stranger."

The breaking of trust and faith is depicted. The problems that suddenly smacked him had caused Elie to lose trust and faith. It also is very difficult not to lose trust and faith. To think positively can be very hard. I think that one thing can be discerned about Elie and that is that he is a fighter, and that he likes to fight. He likes to fight, and this can be discerned. However, he did do what most people would do and that is lose faith in something that they had immense faith in. He had immense faith in God, and now his trust began lessening. The plight had caused him to lose faith in something that he was so keen to learn about, and this keenness had now been demolished. The quote is for this reason meaningful.

Pages 71-80
Page number 73

"I know. One has no right to say things like that. I know. Man is too small, too humble and inconsiderable to seek to understand the mysterious ways of God. But what can I do? I'm not a sage, one of the elect, nor a saint, I'm just an ordinary creature of flesh and blood. I've got eyes too, and I can see what they're doing here. Where is the divine Mercy? Where is God? How can I believe, how could anyone believe, in this merciful God?"

I find this quote meaningful and important because the quote shows again that in this atrocity they had lost something very dear and that is their belief. They began to doubt themselves, and they had given up. Given up because the situation they were in forced them to give up, and lose. I think that this quote claims that hope indeed can be undermined by disarray. The quote shows the dire situation they were in , and how everything shattered. Shattered like the way when glass accidentally falls from a countertop. Like the glass that fell from the countertop, the glass did not want to fall, but the glass had to fall because of the situation it was in. They too did not delibrately break their trust, but like the glass that was bound to fall, and they too unwillingly had to break their trust, and ask more questions.

Pages 81-90
Page number 90

"It was pitch dark. I could hear only the violin, and it was as though Juliek's soul were the bow. He was playing his life, The whole of his life was gliding on the strings-his lost hopes, his charred past, his extinguished future, He played as he would never play again."

The violin is a symbolism of the desire to gain back the lost hope. Juliek wanted to live his life for the last time. His desire was the desire to have everything back to normal, and it was also a rebellion. He wanted to fight the circumstances he was in, and that is why he played the violin. He was dieing but he wanted to do something he had loved to do. He wanted to remember the life he was living, and the life he had once dreamt of. When he played the violin it was as of he had lived all his dreams, and he had gained what he had wanted to. He lived his full life in those few moments , and he wanted to fight. He wanted to fight the situation he was in, so he can dream. So, he can be in a reverie. A reverie where he could live all his dreams, and perhaps gain what he had lost.

Pages 91-100
Page number 100

"The snow began to form a thick layer over our blankets. They brought us bread-the usual ration. We threw ourselves upon it. Someone had the idea of appeasing his thirst by eating the snow. Soon the others were imitating him, As we were not allowed to bend down, everyone took out his spoon and ate the accumulated snow off is neighbor's back. A mouthful of bread and a spoonful of snow. The SS who were watching laughed at this spectacle."

I like this quote, because even in this dire situation they had found a way to survive. Someone was able to use their brains, and was able to conduct a way of obtaining food, and water. My perspective about this quote is that it reveals something about the human nature, and the concept that it teaches is that no matter how much a human might be in a dire situation, the human still learns how to fight, and win its battle. Even though there circumference was enlightened with worries they still were able to contrive or think up a way to survive. They were intelligent to think of snow as a way to suffice their thirst. Even though their are problems, and even though the night seems long. After that night is a beautiful day, and that day will bring it's light. I like this quote, because even though the officers were ridiculing them, they were able to ignore them and they were able to survive, and do their best in this effort.

Pages 101-109
Page number 109

"One day I was able to get up, after gathering all my strength, I wanted to see myself in the mirror hanging on the opposite wall, I had not seem myself since the ghetto, From the depths of the mirror, a corpse gazed back at me, The look in his eyes as they stared into mine, has never left me."

I find this quote meaningful, because he was able to distinguish a change in himself, and he saw this change. He saw that the camps had changed him, and he was able to see that. The camps had not changed his personage, but they had changed him form inside. He was changed man from the inside, and this he could see. I think that the camp had never actually permananetly changed him, I think it was transient change. He had never form his heart changed, it was just the situation and hardships that he was facing that accounted for these types of problems. I believe that Elie had never really changed at all, and that the corpse he had seen was not a corpse; it was just an illusion. I can firmly say this was an allusion because he Knew he was gazing at a corpse. H knew he was that corpse. The corpse he had seen was actually his change, and the death of his beliefs.






0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home